Is Jenna Lyons' decision to step down from J Crew after 26 years a sign that Londoners have fallen out of love with American super-brands?

Fashion visionary Jenna Lyons rocked the style world by exiting J Crew on Monday
1/16
Laura Craik6 April 2017

On the face of it, a six-foot tall fortysomething with false teeth and nerdy librarian specs isn’t the most likely candidate to be exalted as a fashion icon. Yet for more than a decade, Jenna Lyons was exactly that.

As head of design, and eventually president, of the cult American preppie brand J. Crew, Lyons was a bona fide It girl, one with way more style and substance than a Gigi or a Kendall. For a particular genre of woman who always felt slightly bogus "dressing for the office", Lyons was a saviour.

She showed that "workwear" needn’t be a dreary white shirt tucked into a drab grey pencil skirt. Even the most ponderous, unadventurous dresser could enter J Crew and come away convinced that yes, a bib-fronted pinstripe shirt and bright red cropped trousers could genuinely work for them. Add a cropped blazer into the mix and maybe that promotion would be theirs.

"I have never felt more fashionable than the day Jenna Lyons complimented my outfit - a blindingly metallic pencil skirt that I had teamed with a plain T- shirt and flat shoes - because, frankly, she is my style icon," says Jo Elvin, editor of Glamour.

"She completely changed the way I dress, along with millions of others, with the quirky, slightly ‘wrong’ aesthetic she brought to J Crew. Whenever I’m stuck for what to wear, I find myself asking, 'What would Jenna wear?'"

Getty Images

It’s the question many cash-rich, time-poor women have asked themselves during her tenure. Which is why news that Lyons, 48, is to leave the company after 26 years feels more seismic than such announcements usually do. "Jenna and I got together and we both agreed it was time for a change," J Crew’s chief executive Mickey Drexler, 72, told The Business of Fashion on Monday.

"It’s been a great run. There’s a lot of mutual respect between Jenna and me." In a statement, Lyons described Drexler as "one of retail’s most talented visionaries", adding that she was "excited for the next chapter for J Crew as well as the opportunity for other creative leaders within the organisation to step up and take on new responsibilities." J Crew’s current head designer of womenswear, Somsack Sikhounmuong, will be promoted to chief design officer, responsible for women’s, men’s and childrenswear, effective immediately.

The Lyons’ den: J Crew’s store on Regent Street
Rex Features

That Lyons is stepping down is a stark reminder that in fashion you’re only as good as your last retail results. In 2016, total revenues decreased by six per cent to $2 billion, with store sales falling by an average of eight per cent. The company also has debts totalling $1.5 billion, causing insiders to whisper darkly about impending bankruptcy. It’s all a far cry from J Crew’s heyday, when its Tilly sweaters were ubiquitous, its statement necklaces were a fash-pack favourite and Lyons was starring in Season 3 of Girls.

Perhaps Lyons is jumping ship before the ship sinks further. It is surely significant that one of J Crew’s most prominent fans is Michelle Obama, the only First Lady to have worn mass-market clothing with such conviction. Recalling photos from 2009 of Mrs Obama and her daughters dressed in J Crew clothes for Barack Obama’s first swearing-in ceremony, it’s hard not to feel a pang of nostalgia.

Michelle Obama - style file

1/74

Melania Trump is unlikely to wear J Crew. Her husband is equally unlikely to invite Lyons and her same-sex partner to the White House, as the Obamas did in 2013.

But if Lyons’s departure feels like the end of a greater cultural era, it also feels like the end of Britain’s long-running love affair with American fashion - or at least that mass-market portion of it that we once held so dear. It’s not just US politics with which we Brits have become disenchanted: it’s also US style. In the early 2000s, fashion-conscious visitors to New York would hot-foot it to chains such as J Crew, Banana Republic, Club Monaco and Forever 21 to load their baskets with well-cut, exotic-seeming items that seemed pleasingly affordable, thanks to the relative strength of the pound against the dollar.

Yet by the time Banana Republic opened its first UK store in 2008, followed by J Crew in 2013, it was hard not to feel as though they’d already missed the boat. Fast fashion is named thus for a reason: it moves at lightning speed.

So, too, do consumer tastes and preferences. Like fellow US chains Banana Republic (who closed all eight of its British stores after 18 months of poor sales) and Gap (despite revival strategies, sales have been in continual decline for several years now), J Crew has been crushed by the might of H&M and Zara, whose stores are almost as ubiquitous in the US as they are in the UK.

You can’t exit J Crew with a head-to-toe new look - shoes, bag, dress, jacket - for £300: a “pop-stripe Italian cashmere sweater” alone costs £308, though admittedly this is at the top end of J Crew’s price architecture. “It’s just too expensive. Why spend £100 on an off-shoulder top when there are several high-street brands doing it cheaper, with no less attention to fabric or detail?” says Frankie Graddon, fashion and beauty editor of The Pool. “Where once it felt like you could get something a bit different in J Crew, it’s faded into the background. Newer, exciting brands have overtaken it.”

A model sporting the brand’s latest collection

That many of those brands happen to be Scandinavian is of particular note. It’s easy to take the mick out of hygge, but here in the politically uncertain maelstrom that is 2017, “cosy” trumps “preppy” every time. Priorities have changed. Against a sea of genderless, anonymous garb of the sort that Cos and & Other Stories sell, the colour-pop peppiness of J Crew feels out of kilter.

In light of this, perhaps it’s little surprise that sister company Madewell has performed better than J Crew, with sales increasing 14 per cent to $341.6 million in 2016. In many ways, Madewell is its laid-back sibling: its website describes the brand as touting “effortless and tomboy styles”. Significantly, Sikhounmuong was previously head of Madewell’s design team.

Getty Images

It seems wrong that Lyons should be sunk by a predilection for items as “meh” as affordable jeans and boxy-cut sweatshirts but that’s fashion. It also reflects changes in the workplace that perhaps J Crew didn’t see coming.

According to a recent survey conducted by British workwear provider Simon Jersey, only one in four workers would label their employer’s dress code as “smart”, with 36 per cent saying they had introduced a “smart casual” policy. When the CEO of Facebook goes to work in a hoodie, the idea of dazzling the boardroom in a brocade pencil skirt and a diamante necklace seems overblown.

Still, there’s no way this is the last we’ve heard of Lyons. She’ll be back - minus the daytime sequins, maybe - but with another retail masterplan up her sleeves.

Create a FREE account to continue reading

eros

Registration is a free and easy way to support our journalism.

Join our community where you can: comment on stories; sign up to newsletters; enter competitions and access content on our app.

Your email address

Must be at least 6 characters, include an upper and lower case character and a number

You must be at least 18 years old to create an account

* Required fields

Already have an account? SIGN IN

By clicking Create Account you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use , Cookie policy and Privacy policy .

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged in