Twin review: Mini One vs Audi A1

It’s One on 1 in the battle for entry-level posh supermini honours.
1/10
Rob Adams20 October 2016

Small cars these days are not as cheap as they once were.

Just a few minutes in a Ford dealer can have you looking at more than £15,000 for even a mid-range version of the nation’s best-selling car, the Fiesta. Perhaps something a bit posher for similar money would fit the bill instead?

Enter Audi and British BMW-owned small car expert Mini. Both will sell you entry-level versions of their small cars, the A1 SE three-door and Mini One hatch, for well under £15k.

But a posh badge can only go so far. Question is, do they still have premium appeal in their most basic forms?

Both get off to a good start on the road, because both have turbocharged engines. The Mini’s 1.2-litre is actually a bit more powerful, so is the faster of the two. Despite a few flat spots, it generally feels stronger and more flexible than the Audi’s 1.0-litre. The A1 needs more revs, although it is smoother, quieter and easier to drive.

The Mini is, predictably, a blast through the corners. It’s quick-witted and chuckable, with all the playfulness this cute car’s renowned for. Saying that, the A1 is perhaps even more impressive, as it’s eager, better-balanced and has more grip. The pay-off is a choppy ride. Surprisingly, the Mini is a little more forgiving and more composed at speed.

Inside, it’s the Audi that feels more grown up. The driving position is much better, quality is a bit higher and it’s all well laid out and easy to use. The Mini’s interior is more logical than previous versions, but still not particularly functional. It’s not as cramped in the back as you might imagine, though – indeed, it has a bit more headroom and legroom than the A1.

The Audi has a bigger boot, although the latest Mini does have a much larger load area than original models. Crucially, neither is quite as functional as a Ford Fiesta, and only the Audi delivers genuinely premium refinement. The Mini has more road noise, particularly at speed. Coarse road surfaces can be particularly raucous. That upright windscreen generates more wind noise as well.

Given how the Mini has never been the cheapest small car to buy, it’s surprising to discover the Mini One has the cheapest asking price here. Add in discounts and it has an £850 advantage over the A1, but the Audi will retain more after three years, and cost a little less to insure. Overall, it’s probably evens in terms of costs.

Company car drivers may lean towards the Audi. Its slightly higher list price is offset by lower CO2 emissions, which place it two Benefit in Kind bands below the Mini. Sub-100g/km CO2 emissions give the A1 green car bragging rights as well.

Both cars have the essentials in terms of standard equipment: air con, DAB radio, remote locking and electric front windows. The Mini One lacks alloys, but includes the Bluetooth and USB lacking on the Audi. The Mini also has keyless start. But if you want to personalise either of these, you have to move up the range. Only the Mini Cooper is available with racing stripes and a contrast roof colour, for example.

Despite being entry-level versions, neither of these cars will disappoint. The Mini is surprisingly nippy and well equipped, while the Audi is more like a miniature premium exec and may work out cheaper to own. Overall, we think the verve of the Mini gives the One the edge. Good as the A1 SE is, pricier versions make even more sense.

KEY STATS

Audi A1 1.0 TFSI SE (three stars)

Engine size 1.0-litre turbocharged petrol
List price £14,530
Target Price £14,149
Power 95bhp
Torque 118lb ft
0-62mph 10.9sec
Top speed 116mph
Gov't fuel economy 67.3mpg
CO2 emissions 97g/km

Mini One (four stars)

Engine size 1.2-litre turbocharged petrol
List price £14,075
Target Price £13,366
Power 102bhp
Torque 133lb ft
0-62mph 9.9sec
Top speed 121mph
Gov't fuel economy 61.4mpg
CO2 emissions 109g/km

Create a FREE account to continue reading

eros

Registration is a free and easy way to support our journalism.

Join our community where you can: comment on stories; sign up to newsletters; enter competitions and access content on our app.

Your email address

Must be at least 6 characters, include an upper and lower case character and a number

You must be at least 18 years old to create an account

* Required fields

Already have an account? SIGN IN

By clicking Create Account you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use , Cookie policy and Privacy policy .

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged in

MORE ABOUT