The selection dilemmas England face for second Test vs West Indies

AFP/Getty Images
Will Macpherson27 January 2019

The first thing that England got wrong in their First Test defeat in Barbados was their misreading of the pitch, and the selections that confusion caused.

As Joe Root said when picking through the bones of the defeat: “We made a very bold call this week that hasn't quite come off”.

He was referring, of course, to ignoring Stuart Broad and his 433 wickets.

That mistake makes another selection error more likely, so Root also acknowledged that now was not the time for knee-jerk reactions.

After all, England ultimately lost because they were bowled out for 77 rather than selection. It is possible to pick the wrong team and win.

“It would be easy to start making rash decisions off the back of it but we have to take this on the chin in terms of how we play but also in terms of how we look at the pitch and trying to read it a bit better,” said Root.

Here are the dilemmas they need to piece through.

Is Jennings cooked?

Keaton Jennings
Getty Images

Let’s start at the top of the order. Rory Burns looks a settled, measured player who is very comfortable against pace and solid enough against spin. When he makes an error, he is quick to correct it.

His partner Keaton Jennings looks rather less comfortable against pace, even if he has a strong record against spin. The strong suspicion is that he will not last until the Ashes, strengthened further by two dire shots in this match.

England will surely stick with him until the end of the series (not least because the spare batsman Joe Denly is not necessarily the most attractive option to replace him) but he badly needs a score. Antigua is expected to spin, so he has an opportunity to impress – even if that would not prove too much.

Broad back?

Stuart Broad
AFP/Getty Images

Before the tour, Broad probably expected to play in Barbados, and would have understood if he was then left out for an extra spinner in Antigua.

Trouble is, after a defeat like that England are now almost duty-bound to bring him back even if conditions are not as helpful as they were in the First Test. If he does not come in for a spinner, he will surely return for Sam Curran who was a little exposed as an opening bowler.

If he plays from now, it will be as a fourth seamer. Chris Woakes will come into the equation for that role too, perhaps in St Lucia.

How many spinners do you actually need?

Adil Rashid
Getty Images

The success of England’s spinners in Sri Lanka, the attacking threat of Adil Rashid and a dry-looking pitch seduced them into playing two spinners in Barbados (they should have taken note of the Windies’ squad, mind). They had no need for two, especially when West Indies won the toss, meaning England would not bowl last.

They probably will need two in Antigua but Root appears unable to trust Adil Rashid, so Jack Leach may come in for him.

If the turn is going to be extravagant, Leach’s parsimonious left-arm orthodox will be helpful but if the surface is just dull (and, with the series scoreline, the groundsman might be encouraged to make it a little duller), Rashid’s ability to conjure something from nothing would be valued. Then again, so would Leach’s control. He appears to be the favourite.

How many wicketkeepers do you actually need?

Getty Images

If England wanted their options to be really open with the ball by selecting four seamers and two spinners, they would need to drop a batsman. Jennings looks the least likely to score runs, but that would require deploying someone out of position in the highly-specialised openers’ role.

More likely would be dropping one of the wicketkeepers; since Ben Foakes’ emergence in Sri Lanka they have had three in the side. None of them deserve dropping: Foakes had his first average Test in Barbados and dropping him would require finding a new No3 anyway (as Jonny Bairstow would have to move down the order to keep); it is only one match since Bairstow made a century and the No3 experiment needs time to work; Jos Buttler has been superb since returning to the side in May.

Three keepers it is then.

Create a FREE account to continue reading

eros

Registration is a free and easy way to support our journalism.

Join our community where you can: comment on stories; sign up to newsletters; enter competitions and access content on our app.

Your email address

Must be at least 6 characters, include an upper and lower case character and a number

You must be at least 18 years old to create an account

* Required fields

Already have an account? SIGN IN

By clicking Create Account you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use , Cookie policy and Privacy policy .

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged in