Wind-ups not the key to unlocking French

Will Carling13 April 2012

Winding up the French players used to be a very useful tactic for England, but it all started to go wrong as I came to the end of my Test career.

In a very worrying move, the French players actually started controlling themselves and concentrated on playing rugby, something they can do better than any other team in the game.

Thanks to the inventive tricks played by Brian Moore, we had been able - from the late 1980s into the 1990s - to trigger a reaction from the French.

Mooro reached his peak with the assertion that "France are like 15 Eric Cantonas, brilliant but brutal". Nice one Mooro!

During our famous 1991 World Cup quarter-final win over France in Paris, our wing Nigel Heslop was slapped by their captain Serge Blanco, who felt he had been late-tackled, and put on the floor by a punch from Eric Champ. The referee called myself and Blanco over to him and told us to stop the trouble and throughout this chat, Blanco was visibly shaking.

I looked over to the rest of the French team and they were in a similar highly-strung state and when I called our guys together to pass on the referee's warning, I told them: "Look, this lot are almost over the edge, so keep the pressure on."

The response from Pc Wade Dooley, our erstwhile enforcer, was: "Great lads, just keep kicking them."

It took the French a long time to recognise that one of our main weapons was just to wind them up so they stopped playing and wanted to fight. As my career came to a conclusion, they were much harder to get going and by the end they were well disciplined and that was a bad sign.

In the last couple of matches between the teams, I don't get the impression that England can put the French off their game by getting inside their heads like Mooro used to.

Instead, the current French side have been pilloried by their own rugby president and press and that is why the opening 15 minutes will be absolutely crucial at Twickenham on Saturday. If England can really put the pressure on France, maintain their excellent defensive line and frustrate the opposition, then cracks could appear in their fragile self-belief.

However, if the French manage to produce something positive in the opening phases then their confidence will be boosted and they will start believing they really can win. Then, it could become a very long and hard afternoon for England.

I made the mistake of dismissing the French during the 1999 World Cup after their poor form in opening games and when it came to the semi-final with New Zealand, I decided to stay at home rather than use my ticket. What a great judge of rugby I am! I really thought that France would be a joke. I sat back and watched the television coverage as France took New Zealand apart. It was a classic case of ripping up the form book and producing a world-class performance from nowhere. That's what worries me about Saturday's match, but this time I will be using my ticket, although I really hope they don't do it again.

This match offers Steve Borthwick a chance to make a name for himself as replacement for the injured Danny Grewcock. He comes into the team in similar circumstances to Martin Johnson's debut, against France in 1993.

I didn't know much about Martin when he turned up. I tried to have a chat, but he was very quiet and just sat in the meeting and listened. I asked Dean Richards about Jonno and his reply was: "He's a good lad and will do his job." Jonno did it so well he was unlucky not to remain in the team for the whole championship season.

In that instance, Jonno was replacing Wade who was the senior partner in the second row, and Borthwick is taking over from Grewcock, another very good young lock. It is Jonno who is now the old hand and the man who acts as enforcer if things get a little lively. That should help Borthwick deal with his first cap and the pressure the French are going to put on him, especially at the line-out.

For Borthwick, the build-up to this match must appear quite settled because there is no French-baiting to read about. The preparations are now quite sanitised because you don't want to give the opposition anything to feed off. What Mooro did was to offer the French a little bait and see if they would nibble before what always was the game to play in.

The challenge of beating the French brought the best out of us and I hope the same is true at Twickenham on Saturday.

Create a FREE account to continue reading

eros

Registration is a free and easy way to support our journalism.

Join our community where you can: comment on stories; sign up to newsletters; enter competitions and access content on our app.

Your email address

Must be at least 6 characters, include an upper and lower case character and a number

You must be at least 18 years old to create an account

* Required fields

Already have an account? SIGN IN

By clicking Create Account you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use , Cookie policy and Privacy policy .

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged in